Home › Games › Rare items

💎 Rare items : Vintage games: Avalon Hill and 1970s-80s role-playing games

The story

Board and role-playing games of the 1970s-80s have become collectibles. The most famous is the first edition of Dungeons & Dragons (1974), sold in a "woodgrain" box and printed in about 1,000 copies. Storm Over Arnhem, published by Avalon Hill in 1981, simulates the battle for the Arnhem bridge (Operation Market Garden, 1944): a two-player wargame, not rare but sought after. Prices range from a few dozen dollars for a common game to over $20,000 for the very first D&D.

Sources : Wikipedia (Dungeons & Dragons, 1974) · Wikipedia (Storm Over Arnhem)

Why these prices?

  • Print run sets the price: only about 1,000 boxes of the very first D&D edition, hand-assembled by the TSR team.
  • Later editions (white box, from 1976) are less sought after: it is the first three printings, with woodgrain decor, that sell for thousands of dollars.
  • Completeness matters: counters, dice, cards and the box. In our findings, the used copy missing a die went for just over $21.
  • Avalon Hill wargames such as Storm Over Arnhem remain affordable: asking prices are a few dozen dollars, and actual sales lower.

The most expensive found

  1. 🎲See the photos of the sale ↗

    Dungeons & Dragons, first edition woodgrain box (TSR)

    1974
    $22,100Sold

    A first-printing copy, with a hand-coloured die and a student booklet, sold for $22,100 on eBay, a record according to Black Gate. The previous record was below $10,000 according to the Multiverse blog.

    Sources : Black Gate · Multiverse · eBay sale, 9 December 2016

  2. 🎲See the photos of the sale ↗

    Storm Over Arnhem (Avalon Hill, 1981), first edition

    1981
    $125.96 asking priceListing, asking price

    The highest asking price we found for this game's first edition, at an American store.

    Source : Board Game Oracle · listing found on Board Game Oracle

  3. 🎲See the photos of the sale ↗

    Storm Over Arnhem (Avalon Hill, 1981), used box, listed as "rare"

    1981
    $79.99 asking priceListing, asking price

    A used copy with some box damage, listed at $79.99 or best offer.

    Source : eBay · eBay listing at the time of our search

  4. 🎲See the photos of the sale ↗

    Storm Over Arnhem (Avalon Hill, 1981), very good condition

    1981
    C$50Sold

    Sold for C$50 after an offer was accepted. Another used copy, missing a die, had gone for US$21.69 the day before.

    Sources : eBay · eBay (sans un dé) · eBay sale on 3 September

Prices found in the press and on marketplaces during our research of Oct 4, 2026. These are isolated sales, or asking prices where stated: they are not a price guide. Amounts are in their original currency.

← Back to category Games

Archive card

Submit an item

Log in